Conversely, a 1976 "Wonder Woman #1" (signed by both Lynda Carter and creator William Moulton Marston's estate holder) sold for $48,000 on ComicConnect in 2023. The buyer told CGC Magazine , "I didn't buy the paper. I bought the confidence." The Most Sought-After Rachel Steele Verified Items Not all verified items are created equal. Steele herself maintains a private "Tier List" of the rarest Wonder Woman artifacts. Here are the top three: Tier 1: The 1974 Cathy Lee Crosby Rehearsal Script Crosby’s portrayal of Wonder Woman (blonde, wearing a white jumpsuit) is often erased from history. Only three copies of the rehearsals script exist. In 2019, Steele verified a copy with a handwritten note from Crosby to her agent: "They want me to wear a cape. I said no." That script sold for $90,000. Tier 2: Lynda Carter’s 1978 Emmy Consideration Polaroid Carter never won an Emmy for Wonder Woman , but she submitted a "For Your Consideration" package in 1978 that included a signed Polaroid of herself in the costume, backstage. Steele has verified only seven of these. Each one fetches between $12,000 and $18,000. Tier 3: Gal Gadot’s “Fast & Furious” Crossover Signed Stunt Photo While Gadot is the modern Wonder Woman, her signing habits are famously erratic. Steele has verified only 42 authentic Gadot signatures on Wonder Woman branded material. The rarest is a 2015 stunt rehearsal photo from Batman v Superman , signed two years before the film’s release. One sold for $7,500. The Controversy: Is Steele Too Strict? The authentication world is divided. Some dealers accuse Rachel Steele of being exclusionary, arguing that her methods reject genuine autographs simply because they don't fit a narrow "ideal" sample. In 2021, a prominent California dealer sued Steele for defamation after she refused to verify a batch of 1980s Carter signatures, stating the "pressure angle was inconsistent with a standing signing."
While most authenticators refused to touch celebrity autographs due to the variability of rushed signings, Steele developed a proprietary methodology. She didn't just compare signatures to a single "sweet spot" example. Instead, she built a dynamic database of hundreds of examples per celebrity—candid signings at gas stations, rushed signings at conventions, and deliberate signings for charity. rachel steele wonder woman verified
Authentication standards change. Always consult Rachel Steele’s official 2025 updated database before purchasing high-value Wonder Woman memorabilia. This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute an appraisal. Conversely, a 1976 "Wonder Woman #1" (signed by
To the uninitiated, this might sound like a code or a minor character from the multiverse. But to provenance experts, autograph authenticators, and Golden Age enthusiasts, those four words represent the pinnacle of Diana Prince collectibles. In an era where forged signatures flood eBay and celebrity autopens dilute the market, the "Steele Verification" has emerged as the gold standard for Wonder Woman authentication. Steele herself maintains a private "Tier List" of
This article dives deep into who Rachel Steele is, why her verification process matters, and how a signed Wonder Woman item becomes a certified piece of feminist and pop culture history. Before we understand the value of the verification, we must understand the verifier. Rachel Steele is not a fictional character, but a real-world archivist and authentication specialist who has spent nearly three decades documenting the careers of iconic actresses. Her niche? The women who played Wonder Woman.
In 2022, Heritage Auctions sold an alleged "Lynda Carter signed Justice League #1" for $1,200. Six months later, Rachel Steele was hired to verify a private collection that included that exact comic. Her analysis revealed the signature was an autopen—a mechanical signature duplication device—from a 1990s fan club mailing. The auction house had to issue refunds. The comic's value plummeted to $50.
In the sprawling universe of comic book memorabilia, few phrases ignite the passion of die-hard DC collectors quite like “Rachel Steele Wonder Woman Verified.”